Okay, I'm not sure the appropriate place to put this, but it sorta pertains to the situation, so I chose the neutral ground of the UFC, appropriately enough.
TLDR at bottom.
So I gots to get some things off my burly, rippling pectorals here. I apologize in advance if this is offensive to any parties (it is), or if I descend into ranting at any point (I did), it is all in the spirit of trying to make this RP fun for everyone. But mostly me.
So some recent (and less recent) events have happened that I kinda don't agree with, and wish to belatedly express my lack of enthusiasm toward. If you have been keeping up on all of the faction threads, (Hunters, primarily) you may know what I'm talking about.
Base 4. I already made a post in the now-locked thread about this matter, but I feel the need to elaborate. I disagree with this idea for a few reasons, but primary would be believability and staying true to the established Lore we are working off of.
The whole place as described seems far-fetched to me. Firstly, the place seems waay too intricate and well designed. We are a bunch of rag-tag factions here, only recently formed. That many-storied nightmare-prison seems far outside of what I understood our resources to be. Then there's the occupants. Lauren stated in a stream that she wanted Foenum to be populated by 99% 'non-rare' (read mythical) creatures, and there is mention of Rocs, Gargoyles and Kitsune all in this base? What about the mentions of technological powers that seem beyond what modern humans are capable of, let alone what our Ungulates could possibly even dream to CONCEIVE of? I get humor, but it is not worth killing believability, in my mind.
Then there is the number of Predators mentioned, which seems way over-done, (which I already mentioned, and Hurricane offered a possible solution for, but I think this needs to go beyond that). The Hunters, as I understand it, are a group of Ungulates who worship or serve the Predators, and in turn get Predator-esque enhancements and powers - NOT actual Predators themselves (atleast for the VAST majority). This distinction seems to get lost often.
"Oh, but Feanor, you are forgetting the Corn Oil!" Well, no, actually. You see, that is stupid. Stu-PID. The Hold is a MAGICAL prison, with MAGICAL doors, and MAGICAL locks. There is a good possibility that the creatures there are ethereal ghosties, and that their ability to slip through the cracks has no - I repeat, NO - correlation to, nor dependency upon, LUBRICATION.
Furthermore, this magical barrier has held back the Predators for millennia, and barring Prophetess level magic I don't think that anyone or anything could so much as budge this lock (weakened or no) on their own. Maybe all the magic users of Foenum working in concert could have some effect, but that is not the case. And why would we want it to be? The Predators re-entering Foenum would be like the climactic end of the GAME, which we haven't even reached the BEGINNING of yet. Yes, a few disembodied scouts have managed to slip through in the lore (and probably vanished shortly thereafter) but I don't think that is territory that should even be dabbled in for us. At best it should be a VERY rare and exceptional occurrence for anything from the Hold to be seen/interacted with. There is plenty of interesting content to be explored outside of Hell; see Giraffe War and current debacle. That's without even getting into inter-faction conflict. I think the standard OC has set with The Battle of Unruliness was very good, and should be the minimum for realism here.
Secondarily, my objection would be the wrench Base 4 throws in our strategy. That was a lot of time and effort trying to work that out with everyone. To be clear, I don't mind the fact that evacuating the hostage makes our plan a 100% chance failure (even if it does deflate the fun of the attack a bit), I can appreciate that it adds to realism (after all, missions can't be a smashing success all of the time), suspense, and makes the eventual rescue of Fleece all the more dramatic. What bothers me is that it gave us very little room to respond. We could either 'spy' the evacuation happening, and forget our 2 days of intricate strategy to give chase (which would have been rather anti-climactic if we succeeded, imo) or... ignore it, as we did. Leaving us here, facing a base that I don't think could or should exist, and which, if it does, is so absurdly difficult and convoluted that it would take EQUALLY absurd and unrealistic measures to defeat. In the Battle of Unruliness, OC managed to make a simple Giraffe encampment into a dynamic and complex (15 chapters complex!) battlefield. I don't think we need to shoot for crazy complexity here. Maybe just a regular ole Hunter hideout that is better than the Cave but not Alcatraz-on-steroids?
That said, I know I am getting alot into personal opinion here, and that not everyone (or anyone, necessarily) will agree. If this is the way people want to do things, I will ofcourse go along and do my best to be a good sport. I have a G.R.R Martin-ish view on realism and grittiness that might (for some) be at odds with this universe, and I don't ask that it be shared, but I DO think that keeping a more realistic, true-to-the-lore approach would make everything more fun and engaging.
That and keeping our characters (and factions) in relatively equal power ranges. I am pretty new to RP myself, but I don't need to be experienced to see why the Overpowered OC syndrome (Not you, OC), is so dreaded. Sorry Zero. I mean, a bear by itself is a strong pick in this world of hooves and rare magic. A robot bear? That could be indestructable to anything except a very strong magic-user. A ROBOT BEAR WITH A BALLISTIC ARSENAL FROM 10,000 YEARS IN THE FUTURE?! Just. Can't. Reconcile. (SORRY! I know you explained how that ended up happening.) I'm just gonna be honest though, in my head your just a bear (the fluffiest, best bear, ofcourse!). I just can't picture it any other way. I just pretend the transportation had side-effects. You already went through an inter-dimensional portal, surely it's not so far-fetched to think that the translation might have put you to this world as a real creature? Maybe it is a slow process where you are gradually flesh-ified? Or maybe the weapons just run out of ammo and there is no way to get more?! ANYTHING!! (There may be other examples of OPs, I just can't think of 'em instantly).
I also feel like posting this reminder to all and sundry - RP IS NOT ABOUT WINNING!
Think of it like we are all trying to write a story together, taking into account all the accompanying variables such as: believability, pacing, character intelligence (not just your own OC's), deus ex machinas, plot convenience, Mary Sues, etc. Do you fight and arrange things in your story to make your characters win every time? (Answer should be no.) Or do you try to arrange things for the most dramatic, enjoyable story that will keep readers guessing? Your story would be pretty boring if your character won every encounter, wouldn't it? See Stunt's recent
post for example. Did he think he would win? No. He took a 1% chance, but it made for a very fun little event that rang true and ended with a realistic outcome. Magnifique!
Lastly I wanted to just say a few words about all this. I know I am being sarcastic, nit-picky, and
possibly rude, (for which I am sorry) but I need to post these things, because frankly some of them make it hard for me to enjoy myself here. That is part of the reason I have been distant from a lot of the RP for awhile. I understand this is pretty free-form stuff, but some structure and consistency is important, atleast to me. Ofcourse, I could just avoid interacting IC with those things I disagree with (which I have largely done) but in these large-scale events it is damn near impossible, hence my objections. Again, I don't mean to take this too far. This post is primarily for the purposes of clearing my own mind about things, getting some stuff off my chest, and just letting people know where I stand on things in general. I feel like an asshole, and am quite definitely taking this too seriously, but if I don't post it I'll just think it, so what the hell. My god have I really written all of this? I feel like I have been QQing for hours.
TL ; DR: I'm an asshole. I don't like Base 4. I don't believe in robot bears. I want this RP to be more like Game of Thrones (minus the nude scenes. Maybe.) RP is not about winning. (Sorry for double-post.)